Dog Training: Positive Reinforcement vs Traditional Techniques

Whether you’re a first-time pet parent or a seasoned dog lover, understanding the most effective training methods can make a significant difference in both your life and your pet’s.

This guide will dive deep into two primary approaches to dog training: Positive Reinforcement and Traditional Techniques.

A smiling woman teaching tricks to a small dog.


Training a dog is much more than teaching tricks; it’s about creating a well-behaved member of the family who knows how to behave in various situations.

In this section, we will explore why dog training is so essential and provide an overview of what this article covers.

Why Dog Training Is Essential

Dog training is crucial for several reasons. It ensures the safety of both the dog and the people around it.

A well-trained dog is less likely to display undesirable behaviours like excessive barking, jumping, or even aggressive tendencies.

Moreover, training strengthens the bond between the owner and the pet, making for a more harmonious living environment.

Scope of the Article

This article aims to provide an exhaustive comparison between Positive Reinforcement and Traditional Training Techniques. We will examine their efficacy, potential risks, and practical examples.

Additionally, we will offer insights from veterinarians and professional dog trainers to help you make an educated decision for your canine companion.

Woman training her dog to sit in the park

The Importance of Understanding Your Dog’s Behaviour

Before diving into the training methods, it’s essential to understand your dog’s behaviour and psychology.

Knowing why your dog acts in a particular way can make the training process easier and more effective.

Canine Psychology Basics

Understanding canine psychology involves studying the dog’s natural instincts, social structure, and behavioural patterns.

For example, many dogs have a pack mentality and often look up to a ‘leader’. Recognizing these fundamental characteristics can significantly aid in the training process.

Common Behavioural Issues

Common issues such as separation anxiety, aggression, and excessive barking often stem from underlying psychological or emotional factors.

It’s crucial to identify the root cause of these behaviours to effectively address them through training.

Two dogs are getting aggressive while playing in the grass.

The Landscape of Dog Training in Australia

In Australia, dog training has evolved considerably over the years, reflecting changes in our understanding of canine psychology and welfare.

This section will provide a historical perspective on dog training philosophies and discuss modern trends in Australia.

Training Philosophies: A Historical Perspective

Traditional dog training methods in Australia have roots in military dog training, which focuses on discipline and obedience.

However, with advancements in behavioural science, more humane and psychologically sound methods have come into play, like Positive Reinforcement.

Modern Trends in Australia

Recent years have seen a shift towards more humane training methods, emphasizing positive reinforcement and avoiding aversive techniques.

Many Australian dog trainers now hold certifications in animal behaviour and actively discourage punitive measures.

Traditional Training Techniques

Traditional training methods are often rooted in establishing the owner’s dominance and correcting undesirable behaviours through physical means or intimidation. Let’s examine these methods in detail.

A man teachibg a dog using a twig.

What Are Traditional Training Techniques?

Traditional training methods usually involve correction-based techniques. This could include leash corrections, verbal reprimands, or even physical punishment to discourage undesirable behaviours.

Pros and Cons

Like any training approach, traditional methods come with their pros and cons. Below we’ll examine their effectiveness and potential risks.


Some owners find these methods to be effective, especially for immediate behaviour correction.

However, this does not always translate to long-term behavioural change and often requires continual reinforcement.

Potential Risks

Traditional methods can potentially harm the dog both physically and emotionally.

Techniques involving punishment can induce fear, leading to anxiety or even aggressive behaviour in the long term. This can cause aggression toward humans and other dogs when socialising.

Examples of Traditional Training Methods

We’ll look at some specific traditional techniques commonly used in training, explaining how they work.

Choke Collars

Choke collars are designed to tighten around a dog’s neck when it pulls on the leash, thus discouraging the behaviour.

While some find this effective, it poses a risk of physical harm and can be distressing for the dog.

A brown dog wearing a choke collar leash.

Physical Corrections

Physical corrections such as a ‘tap’ on the nose or holding the dog’s muzzle closed are sometimes used to discourage behaviours like barking or nipping.

These methods can be confusing for the dog and could lead to fear or aggression.

Positive Reinforcement Training

Positive Reinforcement focuses on rewarding the dog for good behaviour rather than punishing it for undesirable actions. This section will delve into the details of this training philosophy.

What Is Positive Reinforcement?

Positive Reinforcement involves the use of rewards, usually treats or affection, to encourage desirable behaviours. The idea is that rewarded behaviours are more likely to be repeated.

Pros and Cons

Like any approach, Positive Reinforcement has its strengths and weaknesses. Let’s explore both aspects.


Positive Reinforcement is generally effective for teaching new behaviours and commands. It’s also beneficial for building a trusting relationship between the dog and the owner.

Potential Limitations

One limitation is that it may not be effective for immediate behaviour correction in high-stress or dangerous situations.

It’s also essential to be consistent and timely with rewards for the training to be effective.

Examples of Positive Reinforcement Methods

Let’s examine some popular techniques that fall under Positive Reinforcement.

Treats and Rewards

Using treats or toys as rewards is perhaps the most straightforward form of Positive Reinforcement. The key is to offer the reward immediately after the desired behaviour is exhibited.

Dog treats spilled from a paper bag.

Clicker Training

Clicker training involves the use of a small device that makes a ‘click’ sound to mark the desired behaviour. This is followed by a reward, helping the dog associate the ‘click’ with positive feedback.

Comparing Traditional Techniques and Positive Reinforcement

After examining both methods individually, let’s take a moment to compare them side by side to help you decide which method is more appropriate for you and your furry friend.

Effectiveness in Addressing Behavioural Issues

Both methods have shown effectiveness in different contexts.

While Positive Reinforcement is generally more effective for teaching new behaviours, Traditional Techniques may offer quicker solutions for immediate behaviour correction.

Long-Term Impact on Dog’s Mental Health

Positive Reinforcement tends to create a more trusting and less stressful environment for dogs. Traditional methods, particularly those involving punishment, could lead to anxiety or aggressive tendencies.

Cost Implications

Generally, Positive Reinforcement may involve ongoing costs for treats and toys, whereas Traditional Techniques might require an initial investment in equipment like choke collars.

However, potential vet bills resulting from physical harm or stress-related issues with Traditional Methods could prove more costly in the long run.

Time and Commitment Required

Positive Reinforcement typically requires a consistent and ongoing commitment from the owner.

Traditional Techniques might offer quicker results but often require continual reinforcement to maintain the behaviour.

Expert Opinions

It’s essential to understand what professionals in the field of animal behaviour and veterinary medicine have to say about these training methods.

What Australian Veterinarians Say

Many Australian veterinarians advocate for Positive Reinforcement methods, citing less risk for physical and emotional harm. They generally recommend these methods for a happier, healthier pet.

Insights from Professional Dog Trainers

Professional dog trainers in Australia are increasingly leaning towards Positive Reinforcement, though some still use a mix of techniques depending on the situation.

Professional dog training in a sports field.

Community Opinions and Surveys

Lastly, we’ll delve into what everyday Australian dog owners think about these training methods. After all, practical, real-world experiences can offer invaluable insights.

Feedback from Australian Dog Owners

We surveyed a group of Australian dog owners to gather first-hand experiences with both Positive Reinforcement and Traditional Training Techniques. The feedback was quite illuminating.

Positive Reinforcement: User Experiences

Most respondents who used Positive Reinforcement reported a more robust bond with their pets. They observed that their dogs seemed happier and were more eager to learn.

One dog owner from Sydney mentioned:

“My dog, Coco, used to be anxious and skittish. Positive Reinforcement has not only improved her behaviour but also made her more confident.”

Traditional Techniques: User Experiences

Those who used Traditional Techniques had mixed reviews. While some claimed effectiveness, especially for immediate behaviour correction, others reported increased aggression or anxiety in their pets.

A respondent from Melbourne shared:

“I used choke collars initially, and it did stop my dog from pulling. But he became noticeably more nervous around me.”

Online Surveys and Studies

Several online surveys and academic studies have aimed to quantify the effectiveness of various dog training methods. Here are some noteworthy findings:

Positive Reinforcement: Survey Results

A study published in the ‘Journal of Veterinary Behavior’ found that Positive Reinforcement techniques were associated with lower levels of stress, aggression, and fear in dogs.

Over 70% of Australian dog owners who participated in the survey preferred this method for its humane approach.

Traditional Techniques: Survey Results

Another survey focusing on Traditional Techniques indicated that around 40% of respondents believed these methods to be effective.

However, this same group also reported higher instances of problematic behaviours, including fear-based reactions and aggression.

Combined Methods: Survey Results

Interestingly, a subset of the population used a blend of both techniques.

These dog owners often resorted to Traditional Techniques for immediate behaviour correction but used Positive Reinforcement for teaching new skills and commands.

The satisfaction rate in this group was variable, indicating that a tailored approach might work best for some dogs.

A kid holding a toy while playing with a dog.

Legal Considerations

It’s crucial to be aware of the legal landscape surrounding dog training, especially in Australia. In this section, we will explore relevant regulations and permits.

Australian Regulations on Dog Training

Australia has specific regulations concerning animal welfare, some of which apply to dog training. Methods involving physical harm or extreme stress may be subject to legal consequences.

Permits and Licenses for Dog Trainers

If you’re considering hiring a professional dog trainer, ensure they have the necessary permits and certifications.

This not only assures quality but also ensures that the trainer is compliant with Australian laws and regulations.


Choosing the right training method for your dog is an important decision that will impact both of you for years to come.

Both Positive Reinforcement and Traditional Training Techniques have their merits and drawbacks, and the best choice often depends on your specific situation and your dog’s individual needs.

Like this post? Please share.

Trending Dog Products

Note: We may earn commissions from purchases using the following product links.

Dog waving hand and dog camera dispensing treats towards dog.

360° Auto Tracking Dog Camera

World leading dog camera with with real time alerts, toss treats using remote control and never miss a moment. Ideal for dog's with separation anxiety.

See Best Price

LOYEE Puppy Toys 21 Pack, Small Dog Chew Toys with Rope Toys for Teething Pet Cute Squeak Toy with Treating Ball for Puppy, Small Dogs

21 Pack of Soft, Chew, Squak & Rope Toys

21-piece Luxury Puppy Toy Bundle: Durable, Safe, and Interactive for Teething, Play, and Training - The Perfect Gift for Your Dog!

See Best Price

Rabbitgoo Dog Harness No-Pull Pet Harness Adjustable Outdoor Pet Vest 3M Reflective Oxford Material Vest for Dogs Easy Control for Small Medium Large Dogs, Black, L

No-Pull Harness XS – XL & Various Colours

Enhance your large dog's walks with our Smoky Grey Harness — safe, adjustable, no-pull design for comfort and control.

See Best Price

Flexi Classic Cord Retractable Dog Lead Black Medium 8 Metres

Flexi Classic Retractable Cord Dog Lead 8m

Experience effortless walks with Flexi Classic Cord Lead - automatic, clean, and controlled freedom for you and your dog.

See Best Price

Anti Barking Device, Handheld Ultrasonic Dog Barking Control Devices 16.4Ft Rechargeable Dog Barking Deterrent Device Dog Training Stop Barking No Bark Safe for Dog Indoor Outdoor Anti-Barking Device

Handheld Ultrasonic Anti Barking Device

Revolutionize dog training with Queenmew's Ultrasonic Anti-Bark Device – Safe, Effective, and Portable for Indoor/Outdoor Use.

See Best Price

Orthopedic Sofa Dog Bed - Ultra Comfortable Dog Bed for Large Dogs - Breathable & Waterproof Pet Bed- Egg Foam Sofa Bed with Extra Head and Neck Support - Removable Washable Cover with Nonslip Bottom

Ultra Comfortable & Supportive Dog Bed

Orthopedic Dog Bed: Ultimate Comfort and Support with Waterproof, Washable Design in Various Sizes and Colours.

See Best Price